"Putin and Xi are not our friends." How the West is reacting to Trump's summit in Shenzhen
The first-ever meeting between the leaders of Russia, China, and the United States took place in Shenzhen, China. Following the summit, the parties published a "Declaration on Peace," which mentioned neither Ukraine nor Iran, but did address UN reform and the International Criminal Court. The BBC Russian Service reports on how the Western world reacted to the meeting between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Xi Jinping.
Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, Donald Trump. Photo: Sergei Bobylev/Sputnik, Kremlin Pool Photo via AP
The participants themselves assessed the meeting positively. Chinese leader Xi Jinping called it "positive, constructive, and productive." Russian President Vladimir Putin noted that the Chinese leader "managed to create an atmosphere where a free exchange of views began on certain issues of common mutual interest." In an interview with NBC, Donald Trump rated the meeting "a 12 out of 10."
European Reaction
German Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz, speaking at a press conference following the Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, which also took place on Thursday, stated that "the Yalta format will not bring peace to Europe" and referred to the trilateral meeting in Shenzhen as a "photo op."
European Union leaders have not yet commented on the meeting. At a regular press briefing held just minutes after the publication of the three nations' declaration, the European Commission declined to comment on the document. Diplomatic service spokesperson Christian Wigand merely noted that the European Union supports the UN (and the reforms proposed by Secretary-General António Guterres) as well as the International Criminal Court.
"We do not comment on friendships," added European Commission spokesperson Paula Pinho when asked by an Interfax-Ukraine journalist about how Trump greeted Putin.
"This is my friend," said the US President upon meeting his Russian counterpart in Shenzhen. Trump also called Xi Jinping his friend, with whom he shares a "very special relationship."
The "friendship" between Putin and Trump sparked no fewer comments than the summit's final declaration.
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, for instance, emphasized that "even if President Trump considers President Putin his friend, the principle 'the friend of my friend is my friend' certainly does not apply in this case."
US lawmakers from both parties reacted with irritation to Donald Trump's warm remarks toward America's geopolitical adversaries.
"I was encouraged by the commitments resulting from the president's meetings in Asia, and especially the acknowledgment that a nuclear war should never be fought," Republican Senator John Curtis of Utah wrote in an email to the BBC.
At the same time, he added, "Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping are not our friends."
"We must not treat them as if they share our values and interests. Doing so would risk compromising our national security, eroding the trust of our allies, and sending the wrong signal about America's resolve," he added.
Democrat Jeanne Shaheen, the ranking member on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee (where Democrats will take the majority starting in January), was even sharper in her assessment.
President Trump's "'friend' is a war criminal and a murderer," she wrote on X, referring to Vladimir Putin.
The ICC, the UN, and Image
"The pushback against international norms and courts is the most interesting aspect [of the declaration]. Great powers dictate terms, and the small suffer," Jonathan Eyal of the Royal United Services Institute told Reuters.
Putin, he added, "gained greater credibility and avoided pariah status," while Trump got a "photo-op that he didn't need."
Donald Trump went into the trilateral meeting with a slim agenda and no obvious asks, and apparently came away with little, notes BBC Washington correspondent Anthony Zurcher.
"The pomp and ceremony may, in the end, be just what Trump wanted most," the correspondent suggests.
"It is hard not to notice the condemnation of the International Criminal Court, which has recently become the target of US ire," Zurcher adds. —
If there is one thing the leaders of the three world powers can agree on, it is that multilateral international bodies trying to enforce international law should not have the real teeth to do so."
NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte offered an evasive response to the meeting of the US, Chinese, and Russian leaders.
"I think it is important that leaders have meetings like the one in China," he said. "I think that's fine, so it doesn't worry me at all."
"Do not forget that Russia and the US are major nuclear powers. China is also a nuclear power that is building up its capabilities. It is important that leaders of nuclear powers meet, so it is completely normal that they try to agree on the best way forward," Rutte added.