Palchys responded to the grievance — "why people were led along the avenues" in 2020
Former political prisoner Eduard Palchys, who was involved in coordinating popular protests in 2020, acknowledges that this is indeed an important question and suggests, given that human memory is very selective, recalling a few things from that time.

1. By August 2020, almost all prominent "street" (and not only) leaders had been detained — Statkevich, Sevyarynets, and others were in prison. Repressions and the search for people to detain continued throughout July 2020.
2. Even before August, the regime was actively preparing at airfields and other locations specifically for a harsh, violent scenario — videos of such preparations were actively posted back then. We were even informed about drills with grenade launchers, which at the time was perceived as absurd and cringe.
OMON and special forces units were sent to regional cities to train local police officers. This was at a time when many naive people were still thinking about signatures, complaints, and candidate registrations.
3. Back in July, Nexta was posting leaked plans showing how security forces were thoroughly drilling operations on Independence Avenue. Anyone who went to the square in 2010 and also remembers the 2017 dispersal knows how thoroughly security forces had worked out every courtyard and meter.
4. Nobody knew for sure or realized that August 9 would unfold according to an extremely brutal scenario. Prior to that, the 2010 election had been considered "brutal," where everyone was allowed to gather on Kastrychnitskaya Square and march, and only then was Independence Square quickly cordoned off and 700 people detained, along with almost all presidential candidates.
5. As early as the afternoon of August 9, internet connectivity began to fail. It only fully returned on August 12 — if not for Psiphon, things would have been even worse. Proper coordination was practically impossible. Security forces flooded central Minsk and began detaining passersby as early as around 8:00 PM, a full 2 hours before the main demonstration.
6. I think those who were at the Stella remember very well how many people were there — very few. Only a few thousand — yet these were the bravest and most active Belarusians. At first, no one was prepared for a real war to begin. Russian journalists with war-zone experience posted on social media about how terrified they were.
I remember the ultras, and I remember the youth who showed no fear and caught stun grenades right at themselves. There were a couple of hundred of them.
The bulk of the people remained at home, were at polling stations, or were driving around the city in cars, watching from the sidelines.
7. And then on August 10, those who had been at polling stations on the 9th decided to take to the streets. After debate, our chat came up with the idea that it was dangerous to concentrate people in a single location following the brutality that had been displayed. Therefore, actions were announced across various neighborhoods.
And here many have forgotten that while at Bangalore and other spots some were building barricades, others were shouting: "Provocateurs!", "Don't touch the benches!", "We are for peaceful protest!". And believe me, at first there were far more of the latter than the former.
8. In the days that followed (August 11–12), all events took place in an almost completely decentralized manner due to the complete internet shutdown. During these same days, security forces went to the homes of all ultras, anarchists, and other active individuals.
Besides Mikita Kryutsou, who was found hanged, people from the football fan movement were found with fractured skulls on the outskirts of the city (according to reports from that time). Many football ultras simply fled the country in August to save themselves.
9. When the internet was restored and people were in shock over what had happened, strikes began (a separate topic), women started taking to the streets, and other local actions took place. That is how the idea for the massive march on August 16 was born.
Initially, the gathering was planned on Independence Square. But the notorious pro-Lukashenka rally of extras was quickly scheduled there, so the gathering was redirected to the Stella. A huge number of buses carrying security forces were amassed at Dynamo Stadium.
Security forces were also at the Stella on August 16, but when the first 50,000 arrived, they relocated.
10. During the first march towards the Palace, half the column simply turned onto Tsimiryazeva Street and did not proceed further. Because people were afraid.
When the march to Drazdy towards Yarmoshyna's house was announced, a lot of people wrote that it was a provocation and that Nexta had lost their minds putting people in danger like that.
And when we talk seriously about achieving at least any strategic victories in such standoffs, it most often requires multi-faceted pressure: the street + strikes + a political organization that assumes power.
Of these, our chat was best suited to coordinate the street and provide at least some assistance with strikes. News about them had begun circulating even before August 9, as factory workers had started sending hints to Nexta about such a possibility. But former or active KGB operatives work at every major enterprise, and they quickly began pressuring active workers.
With political organization, however, everything turned out to be far more complicated. Sviatlana was forced out to Lithuania, the rest were jailed, and many people were serving administrative arrests or were in hiding.
Stsiapan could not simply go on a livestream and say: "Officials, security officers, and trade union figures, message me privately and I'll give you all the instructions!". He was only 22 years old and at times was in shock himself from events, considering that the Nexta bot could receive up to 2,000 messages per minute during peak hours. A politically bold figure or organization was needed.
This is where the story of the Coordination Council's establishment begins — it was precisely a logical attempt to formalize political representation. But at the same time, it was also the slowest, most hesitant process. I will not yet write about the conduct of specific individuals and groups in August–September 2020: I think that time will come later.
That is why I also have a question for all armchair warriors, strategists, and analysts. I realize that you personally could easily have swatted APCs aside with your palm and torn barbed wire with your teeth. But you seem to have forgotten that a much larger mass of people in August–September was gathering various signatures, filing complaints, and visiting deputies in an effort to bring them to their senses.
Many have forgotten that when a large column of self-organized people marched on August 17 towards Akrestsina to demand the release of detainees, their path was blocked by ordinary volunteers, priests, and medics who feared that detainees would be killed or tortured if an attempt was made to free them.
And starting from the second half of September, even the overall coordination and route of marches were determined by the people themselves, adapting to the situation on the ground. One could announce — let's gather here and go there, but ultimately the column moved unpredictably, reacting independently to the actions of security forces. This was precisely what made it possible to hold the street for a very long time.
Therefore, looking at it coldly and soberly through the prism of global experience, when war was declared on you back in July and preparations began in advance for complete suppression, yet you managed to keep the adversary under extreme tension until the end of the year — that is a miracle, not a failure.
I realize that some people immediately want to bring up the example of the Maidan in Ukraine. Friends, you don't install iOS apps on Android smartphones, yet you think it's fine to transfer the Ukrainian experience under Yanukovych's lightweight pseudo-regime onto an extremely brutal Soviet-style regime that was built over decades.
The history of the strike movement (which was immediately suppressed) and the political organization (whose members they also began physically jailing in September) are separate topics and problematics. So the marches and the street became the primary instrument of 2020 because that was natural and logical given the circumstances of the time.
The only thing that seems strange to me is why, after serving more than 5 years in prison, one has to come out and, here in freedom, explain things obvious to everyone, which political prisoners year after year usually explain to common criminals in penal colonies.
-
Charniaŭskaja on the "Bykhaŭ Madonna": Most talents are underground or in emigration. So, choose from what they give
-
Kirkevich on the "Bykhov Madonna": A quiet, thoughtless gaze into nowhere — the sculptor captured the state of soul of Lukashenka's Belarus
-
Kuchynski — to Kastsiuhova: I want to ask you not to rewrite history
Comments