From editorial

Tsikhanouski and Karach generated a 50-page "monitoring report" on the activities of "Nasha Niva". What is wrong with it?

In one of the points, it even went so far as Tsikhanouski—the author of the report—accusing "Nasha Niva" of… his own words.

Volha Karach, photo commons.wikimedia.org / Boelnorra; Siarhei Tsikhanouski, photo from Facebook

The website of "Our House" published a 50-page "monitoring report" alleging that "Nasha Niva" targets democratic activists. This text was not written by a human, but by artificial intelligence. This is evidenced not only by the monotonous structure of the points and the AI-typical vocabulary, but also by the metadata of the PDF file, created using Python-docx.

The authors of the report are Siarhei Tsikhanouski and Volha Karach's "Our House". Both appear in it as "victims" as well.

Such lengthy texts are often designed under the assumption that no one will read them closely.

However, we took every case from the report and re-read the articles it refers to. We checked all the cited cases against the original texts. Not a single grievance was confirmed in the form presented in the report.

1. "Our House" and Tsikhanouski pass off documented facts as "unproven"

Volha Siamashka and Fiodar Harbachou. Harbachou's second passport in the name of Viktar Makaveyeu is confirmed by two independent sources. The first is BelPol's photo analysis: artificial intelligence estimates the probability that Harbachou and Makaveyeu are the same person at 99.99992%. The second is the Cyber Partisans: the passport database contains two passports issued to the exact same person. Siamashka's position is cited in the same text.

Cover passports under a different name in Belarus are issued only by the special services, for their own operational purposes. There can be no other explanations here.

Another story involves a screenshot published on the channel of blogger Virus. Siamashka does not deny that she was the one who took the screenshot. According to her, she gave it to another person. This explanation (the position of the other side) is included in the article.

Sviatlana Haluza. The case of Andrei Stryzhak's former assistant does not rely solely on BYSOL's version, as the report claims. Both sides speak about the leak: both the one whose correspondence was leaked and the one who published it. In March 2021, Ilya Biahun himself stated that the leaks came from a woman who made them while serving as Stryzhak's personal assistant. As early as January 2021, NN named Haluza as his source. In 2022, the editorial team asked Haluza for a comment. The illness in the 2025 text is mentioned with a note that Haluza had overcome it.

Karach and the "deserters". "Our House" is involved in defending people who allegedly refused to serve in the Belarusian army and fled abroad. The conclusion that "there are no real cases" from the article about the Ludwig Baumann Prize relies on a 2023 NN investigation. Both men named by "Our House", as it turned out, had left Belarus long before 2022. The statistics allegedly maintained by the organization were not found by journalists: they still have not appeared four years later. The question regarding "pacifist activity" remained unanswered: "Our House" stated that it does not provide comments.

"Narodnaya Hramada". The article about party members filing reports to the KGB was based on a hacked database of appeals, the authenticity of which had been confirmed previously. The editorial team asked the individuals involved for a comment: Bialiutsin refused to comment, and Tsishkevich did not respond. The party itself suspended Pavel Bialiutsin's membership and expelled him from the list of candidates for the Coordination Council.

2. What has been confirmed by facts, "Our House" and Tsikhanouski present as editorial speculation

Dzmitry Skindzerau. The headline stating that Lithuania considers him a threat to national security and intends to strip him of his status corresponded to the notice he received. The text noted that he was given five days to mount a defense. This was later confirmed: on November 3, his refugee status was revoked, and a decision was made to deport him from the country.

The report also criticizes the publication of details about Skindzerau's family and his border crossings. But in the investigation, they are essential for evidence. Details about his family demonstrate that the companies and shares Skindzerau claimed were his actually belonged to relatives. The dates from the "Passenger Flow" database refute his version of the escape. He himself claimed that he left on January 7, 2021. According to the database, he returned from Vilnius on December 24, 2020, spoke at a meeting of the Vitebsk City Executive Committee on December 30, and only flew out of the country on January 15, 2021.

Anatol Kotau. The headline about Kotau conveyed the conclusion of an investigation by the Belarusian Investigative Center (BIC), OCCRP, and DW. Reuters also noted that it was unclear why the dissident knowingly boarded a boat heading toward Russia. Later, in August, a source close to the investigation reported that the main theory of Polish investigators was Kotau's possible intelligence activity. BIC criticizes this theory, and NN presented their position in the same article.

Aleh Barshcheuski. On March 27, 2024, NN wrote that Volha Karach's husband would not be deported. The editorial team cited Lithuanian lawyers and the fact that Karach herself soon began referring to deportation merely as a possibility. A few days later, the head of the Migration Department refuted the information about deportation spread by "Our House". Barshcheuski was not deported.

3. "Our House" and Tsikhanouski attribute things that are simply not in the texts

Yauhen Vilski. The report claims that NN linked Vilski, head of "Narodnaya Hramada", to Yauhen Dudkin, who confessed to working for the KGB. In the article about Dudkin, Vilski is mentioned once: as the leader of the party with which Dzmitruk and Dudkin's group formed a coalition. Vilski is not accused of any involvement with the KGB.

Alena Dziadziulia. According to the report, NN linked her to GUBOPiK. In the article dated August 9, 2026, there is no such claim. It covers Dzmitry Skindzerau's contacts with GUBOPiK, while Dziadziulia is only mentioned as having circulated information about his press conference. The editorial team asked Dziadziulia for a comment, and the text notes this: she did not reply prior to publication.

Belarus Democratic Forum. The report states that NN presented the Forum as an attempt to seize leadership from Tsikhanouskaya. In NN's article of August 8, 2022, there is no such claim. It lists the 17 members of the National Council and outlines the Forum's plan. Regarding Tsikhanouskaya, it is only noted that neither she nor Pavel Latushka and their teams attended the event.

Veranika Tsapkala. It is claimed that an attempt is being made to artificially link her to the "Russian world". However, the text provides all the dates: in January 2021, Tsapkala became the head of the Belarus Democratic Forum, which until 2015 was headed by Viachaslau Dziyanau. Journalists requested a comment from Tsapkala.

4. The subjects' own words are presented as distortions

Ruslan Khazin. The report labels as "slander" the news that the 200,000 euros offered to Siarhei Tsikhanouski after his release by Khazin and Yapishka were actually Leonid Nevzlin's money. It also objects to Khazin being referred to as an electrician in the article.

Yet the source of this information was Tsikhanouski himself. He was the one who recounted that on August 6 he met Khazin in Warsaw and that the latter stated he was an electrician, not a businessman, and that an offer of money from Nevzlin followed. Now Tsikhanouski, as the author of the report, faults the Editorial Team for quoting his own words.

Denials about Tsikhanouski moving to the US. The report cites them as an example of categorical rebuttals that were subsequently unconfirmed. Both of these articles ("Siarhei Tsikhanouski moving to the US? No, a lie", August 4, 2025; "New fake of conspiracy theorists and propagandists", September 16, 2025) rely on Siarhei Biaspalau, a member of Tsikhanouski's team at the time. The first time, he stated that there was no talk of any move. The second time, he explained that the driver's license was issued using an ordinary visa and passport. The refutations worked in Tsikhanouski's own favor.

Siarhei Biaspalau. The interview with the former press secretary was published under a headline that immediately signals it is his subjective assessment ("Biaspalau's cry from the heart…"). NN published Tsikhanouski's reply that same evening, and Prakopyeu's response separately.

Yauhen Karavulau. The report claims that the headline "said yes" to an offer of cooperation with the KGB omits the context of coercion. But this is a quote from Karavulau himself, while the pressure on his relatives and threats are described in detail in the text, citing him. In his own words, he agreed to cooperate with the special services, and he was ordered to remain silent. The call from the KGB took place on June 25, yet Karavulau spoke about it publicly only in September.

Valery Tsapkala. The statements that Andrei Stryzhak's main hater "is Valery Tsapkala", and that he "lives in the ideologemes of the Russian world", are Stryzhak's own words. In the headlines, they are presented in quotation marks as citations. The article about the foundation with Bandarchuk includes comments from Tsapkala, Anatol Bandarchuk, and Anatol Liabedzka. The headline about bot farms begins with "Tsapkala:".

Siarhei Sparysh. This refers to a review of a public broadcast in which he indeed criticized Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya on the platform of a Lithuanian "anti-Litvinist" blogger.

Vital Kandratsenka. He spoke about his work in delivery and his work schedule himself in an interview with the Russian outlet Sota.

5. The other side was given a voice, yet the report claims otherwise

Volha Karach. Back in April 2021, NN published Karach's response to Ihar Makar's accusations, and in 2025—Yuras Ziankovich's refutation regarding "Karach's guarantees". The headline of the refutation is a quote from Ziankovich himself: "Of course, I wouldn't have gone to Moscow under Volha Karach's guarantees."

Pavel Ussau. The report reproaches us for not asking Ussau for a comment regarding the news about Polish services. But NN published his position the day before, on January 10, 2026: back then he called the situation "terrible" and blamed Tsikhanouskaya's circle. The news item with three sources from January 11 was a verification of his own public version.

Uladzimir Niakliayeu. The text criticized in the report—a column by Siarhei Navumchyk in "Opinions"—is a response to an essay by Niakliayeu, which NN itself had previously republished.

6. Polemics and public information

Dzmitry Balkunets. He recounted himself that after EHU he studied in postgraduate school at Russia's Higher School of Economics (HSE). Andrei Suzdaltsev taught at the Higher School of Economics and supervised dissertations on post-Soviet affairs there, while Balkunets himself worked on the same subject. Both publicly appeared together as HSE experts. The ironic headline "Balkunets will handcuff himself to the railway. Well, almost" does not alter the facts, and the facts were taken from Balkunets's own statements.

Anatol Fiodarau. The description aligns with his public position. Following this, NN also published an article about fundraising for his medical treatment, complete with payment details.

What we could have done better

There are a few observations with which we agree, although they alter neither the substance nor the conclusions of our articles and investigations:

  • In the news item about Khazin "It became known what 200 thousand euros were offered to Siarhei Tsikhanouski by 'Belarusian businessmen'", the subhead about Nevzlin should have been presented with attribution to Tsikhanouski, rather than as an established fact.
  • It appears that describing Balkunets as "Suzdaltsev's postgraduate student" is technically inaccurate. It is more accurate to call him a disciple of Suzdaltsev.
  • Skindzerau should have been sent questions prior to the publication of the investigation.
  • In the 2025 text about Haluza, a link should have been provided to Biahun's earlier confession as well, not only to BYSOL.
  • In the article about the Baumann Prize, a link to the 2023 investigation should have been added.

The authors of the "monitoring report" attempted to show that NN's articles about certain figures or their actions are groundless. But, as shown above, the Editorial Team's conclusions are based on facts or the statements of the figures themselves.

We believe that the objective of publishing this so-called study is to generate informational noise and confuse people. The objective of our articles, on the other hand, is to provide a complete picture of what is happening in the Belarusian democratic community.

Comments

  • Санта Бэрримор
    17.11.2026
    От два сапога - Карач и Тихановский. Обиженные жизнью. Смех и слезы.
  • У-у-у-у-у
    17.11.2026
    Тихановский и Карач - два дебила это сила. Совместный докладик Оли с Сярожыкам еще одно косвенное доказательство, что Гапон-Сярожа таки получил мильён налом от расейцев, потратил 100 штук, остальное 900 штук нашли доблестные гэбисты к него за диваном. Незадолго до этого мильён на раскачку трудящихся масс беларусов в 20 году предлагали другу Карач Скиндереву, которого теперь выпирают из Литвы как угрозу нацбезопасности. Про предложение от "неизвкстных" рассказал сам Скиндерев
  • Бульбасрач
    17.11.2026
    Бульбасрач 👍

Now reading

Crimean Bridge destroyed by Ukrainian missile strike

All news →
All news

Russian hockey player who spent almost his entire career in Belarus went to conquer Ukraine and was killed 1

30-year-old blogger Maksim Pushkin had a second hair transplant. How much did he pay? 16

Missing Russian Z-War Correspondent Romanov May Have Been Accused of High Treason 5

Workplace investigates doctor over insults directed at woman with disability 6

A woman bought "Little Bottles" chocolates with no liqueur inside. Why? 5

Construction of a new Catholic church has begun in Minsk 8

Even Men Came to Kadysheva's Concert in Minsk Wearing Kokoshniks 92

Trump believes Putin could have acted even tougher in Ukraine 12

Details Have Emerged of an Armed Robbery Involving a Handgun in Minsk 1

больш чытаных навін
больш лайканых навін

Crimean Bridge destroyed by Ukrainian missile strike 40

Crimean Bridge destroyed by Ukrainian missile strike

Main
All news →

Заўвага:

 

 

 

 

Закрыць Паведаміць